Monday, April 29, 2013

"Proving Shakespeare" Webinar Transcript

Click here for a transcript of the April 26 "Proving Shakespeare" webinar with our own Ros Barber, author of The Marlowe Papers, debating Shakespeare Birthplace Trust's Stanley Wells and Paul Edmondson.  Super job, Ros!


Editor's Note:  Congratulations to Ros Barber, whose "tour de force" The Marlowe Papers has made the Authors Club Best First Novel shortlist and Desmond Elliott Prize longlist.

Saturday, April 27, 2013

Isabel Gortázar, R.I.P.

We are greatly saddened by the passing this week of International Marlowe-Shakespeare Society co-founder Isabel Gortázar, in Las Arenas-Getxo, Spain. Isabel was an extraordinary woman and a passionate and tireless Marlovian scholar. We will miss her immensely.

 

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Free Webcast of April 26 Authorship Discussion!

Follow this link for free registration for this Friday's Shakespeare authorship discussion at the Stratford-upon-Avon Literary Festival between MSC contributor Ros Barber and Shakespeare Birthplace Trust's Paul Edmondson and Stanley Wells.  This webinar is sponsored by Cambridge University Press.  Should be very interesting!

Friday, March 22, 2013

Praying We See the Light by Anthony Kellett

“There is no God but God, and his name is William Shakespeare.” 
Harold Bloom, in his foreword to Living with Shakespeare, a new anthology by Susannah Carson.
In 2003, preceding Bloom’s revelation, Bill Browning, then Head of English at King’s School, Canterbury, quoted Jonathan Bate when he said, “As soon as you have a God, you have apostates."

So, let’s examine that statement.  Rephrased, it could be stated as: “Shakespeare is a God, and therefore you will always get people who renounce their faith in him and who may be shunned by the members of their former religion."

Yes, I think Jonathan Bate was correct; that is exactly how it is with the Stratford man and his followers. But should we really tolerate such an attitude in academics, studying and teaching a factual subject to our children?

Bill Browning went on, in that same interview in Mike Rubbo's documentary film Much Ado About Something, to claim that looking at the authorship issue is just a substitute activity for studying the plays. “It doesn’t really help us," he commented.  Is that true, too?  Carson’s book claims “we live in Shakespeare’s world,” an environment that has been “fine-tuned for us” by a poet whose vision is so potent “that it’s difficult to conceive who we would be” if he’d never existed.  If true, is it not valid that we examine the author of these works?  Carson’s book speaks of the poet’s vision, of how he, the poet, affects our lives.  Surely, this compels us to examine more than the works alone.

Notwithstanding this, does it not strike anyone else as a little sad that a Head of English, at the school of Christopher Marlowe, Hugh Walpole and Somerset Maugham, believed that the biography of the author should be considered irrelevant and that we should read the works in isolation from their creator?  I wonder what Somerset Maugham would think of that viewpoint.  

It was sometimes said that Maugham’s years as a medical student were unproductive, creatively.  Yet Maugham himself said in his Summing Up: 
I saw how men died. I saw how they bore pain. I saw what hope looked like, fear and relief; I saw the dark lines that despair drew on a face; I saw courage and steadfastness. I saw faith shine in the eyes of those who trusted in what I could only think was an illusion and I saw the gallantry that made a man greet the prognosis of death with an ironic joke because he was too proud to let those about him see the terror of his soul.
How can anyone reading that quote for the first time fail to have a heightened emotional awareness when they read a Maugham passage which may have been coloured by these experiences?

When he wrote Liza of Lambeth, Maugham drew on experiences he had as a midwife in Lambeth.  At other times, he drew on knowledge gained as a secret service agent in Russia during the 1917 revolution, as did Walpole, in no small way.

Walpole sets one of his most famous books in Cumberland, so it comes as no great surprise he had a house near Derwentwater in that county.  He tentatively explored an ecclesiastic career before abandoning the idea, yet it manifested itself in his writing, along with his exploits for the Propaganda Bureau in Russia.

I have no doubt that many people enjoyed the writings of these men, oblivious to their background.  If all one wants from a book is a "good yarn," then that is neither to be criticized nor lamented.  However, surely the Head of English, at such an eminent school, should have higher goals and aspirations than that, should he not?  Should we not be illustrating to students how the life of the author influenced the themes within his works, so that they may become more connected, too?  It seems to me that the expression of "self" in any art, be it written, painted, sculpted, designed or composed, is exactly the kind of skill that will yield the next generation of artistic talent. If students are taught creativity is born solely from imagination, without any personal emotional content, is art not bound for a bland, formulaic, and sterile future?  

The authorship debate is gold dust, in this respect.  It is not only a perfect vehicle for exploring personal content in varied works, by numerous authors, then relating those to the Shakespeare canon, for what that might reveal about its author; it is also a way to teach young people how to question preconceived ideas and dogma.  It can teach them how to reason from basic principles. It teaches them not to blindly accept what they are presented as fact, to analyze data for themselves, and to debate their findings with others.
 
It seems to me that the authorship debate is the perfect vehicle to introduce pupils to the art of debating and thereby to political debate and politics itself.  It can teach them the application of logic, history, scientific method, archaeology, documentary research, economics, philosophy — as well as the genius of the plays themselves.  Moreover, all these myriad "angles" open the possibility that pupils will find these works far more interesting and alluring.  At present, we merely sit them down to learn what they perceive as a foreign language, as something serving no purpose other than to pass a meaningless exam, which they do not value.  I think it is time for a different approach, and we may yet produce a generation excited by Shakespeare and the works we all love. 

I want young people to start their lives, in this complex world, with a knowledge and understanding of the lessons in Shakespeare.  Unfortunately, most never learn them; and even those that do, tend to do so far too late in life.

 © Anthony Kellett, March 2013

Also by Anthony Kellett:  "Shakespeare's Anonymous Death"; "William Shakespeare, Businessman - Forgotten Genius"; "Shakespeare Scholars: A Lament"; "A Case for Marlowe - Made Simple"

Click here for the blog's home page and recent content.

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Ros Barber Finalist for Women's Prize for Fiction

Congratulations to MSC contributor Ros Barber, who is a finalist for the prestigious Women's Prize for Fiction (formerly the Orange Prize) for her verse novel The Marlowe Papers. Click here for the Los Angeles Times article.

Friday, January 18, 2013

Humanizing Marlowe: a Question for Ros Barber

Q:  Ros, as you prepare for the January 29 U.S. release of The Marlowe Papers, which debuted to excellent reviews in the U.K., can you shed some light on Christopher Marlowe the man whom a prospective reader of your novel might not be at all familiar with?  It is rare to find even Dr. Faustus on a U.S. high school curriculum, for example, and thus many would be reading about Marlowe for the very first time.  Why is he such a compelling figure worthy of our attention?

RB:  Thanks, Carlo.  Always happy to talk about my favourite dead man!  There are so many aspects of Marlowe I want to cover in my response that I think I’ll have to give them sub-headings. 

Marlowe as Shakespeare’s genius 

Without Marlowe, we wouldn’t have Shakespeare.  And I’m not just saying that because I’ve written a novel based on the theory that William Shakespeare was Marlowe’s posthumous pen-name! Marlowe’s plays and poems were such an enormous influence on Shakespeare’s that scholars agree Shakespeare wouldn’t write the way he did if Marlowe hadn’t existed. 

Harold Bloom said “Marlowe, himself a wild original, was Shakespeare’s starting point." And Marlowe was not only a starting point. Robert Logan observes “Marlowe’s influence rooted itself in Shakespeare and […] continued to thrive […] for the remainder of Shakespeare’s career.”1

Shakespeare copies and paraphrases Marlowe all the way through the canon.  “The face that launched a thousand ships” is just one of many direct steals. Shakespeare references Marlowe’s poetry in As You Like It and comically mangles it in Merry Wives of Windsor. His Richard II leans heavily on Marlowe’s Edward II, his Merchant of Venice reworks the Jew of Malta, his Anthony and Cleopatra rests on Dido Queen of Carthage and his Prospero is the mirror-image of Marlowe’s Faustus.  If you want to know what makes Shakespeare a genius, do what he does: look to Marlowe.

Marlowe as an innovator

Shakespeare aside, Marlowe was an astonishingly innovative writer. Though he didn’t exactly invent blank verse drama, there was only one notable example before Marlowe took to it, and he was the first person to make blank verse sing off the page.  He set the trend not only for blank verse drama but for English History plays, and spawned a huge number of imitators.  Like Shakespeare, his plays are best experienced in performance rather than read, but they remain vivid, witty and acutely observed.  Professor Tom Healy has said that Doctor Faustus outperformed all of Shakespeare’s plays for popularity from the late 1580s until civil war closed London’s theatres in 1642. Though he was disparaged as an atheist and blasphemer after his death, and subsequently forgotten for centuries, Marlowe was undoubtedly an incredibly gifted, daring and ground-breaking writer. 

Marlowe as a secret service agent

Unlike the man from Stratford, Marlowe was also extraordinarily interesting beyond his writing talents.  He was recruited to work for the government’s fledgling intelligence service while still a university student. When Cambridge University was threatening to withhold his Master’s degree, five of the most powerful people in the land vouched for him, including the Lord Treasurer, Lord Chancellor, Lord Chamberlain of England, and the Archbishop of Canterbury.  He was said to have “done Her Majesty good service touching the benefit of his country." Later he was arrested in the Netherlands for counterfeiting coins, most probably while trying to infiltrate a Catholic plot to assassinate Queen Elizabeth I.2  Marlowe was James Bond in a doublet and hose.

Marlowe as a free thinker

A free-thinker, Marlowe was connected to some of the most brilliant intellectuals of his day.  We’re told he delivered an “atheist lecture” to Sir Walter Raleigh and his followers, and he was a friend of Thomas Harriot, the first person to make a drawing of the moon using a telescope.  In his own words, he was “very well known” to Henry Percy, the 9th Earl of Northumberland, known as The Wizard Earl for his experiments in alchemy. 

If you want to know what Elizabethan intellectuals talked about, Marlowe’s views were controversial enough to spawn an apparent transcript of the playwright in full conversational flow: The Baines Note,3 penned by an enemy intent on bringing about his downfall, tells us Marlowe said that “the first beginning of Religion was only to keep men in awe," and that “Christ was a bastard and his mother dishonest."
 
Marlowe’s views are seeringly sceptical and modern: considered scandalous in earlier centuries, he’d be very much at home in ours.

Marlowe as everyman

But though he mixed with nobility and courtiers, and well as writers and musicians, Marlowe came from humble origins: his father was a cobbler.  His advancement in society came from a combination of aptitude and hard work: a late scholarship to King’s School Canterbury was followed by another to Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, where he earned the title generosus (gentleman) through gaining his Master’s degree. Though an exceptional person, Marlowe was no elitist, bringing with him a breadth of social experiences.  He has been called an over-reacher, he was certainly deeply flawed – but his flaws only make him more human.

Marlowe as a mystery

As if he wasn’t interesting enough in life, Marlowe’s biography concludes with a fascinating murder mystery.  Scholars are torn over whether he really did die in a knife-fight in a tavern, or whether the inquest was a cover-up for something shadier.  Both named witnesses, and the supposed murderer, were professional liars – conmen and spies. Two of them worked, like Marlowe, in the intelligence service and the man who is said to have stabbed him through the eye was a lifelong servant of Marlowe’s patron. There is a huge amount of material here for amateur sleuths to get their teeth into, and at the moment the mystery remains unsolved.

Here are more than enough reasons, I hope you agree, to make Marlowe a compelling figure worthy of our attention.

 © The Marlowe-Shakespeare Connection, January 2013
New York Times review of The Marlowe Papers
1Harold Bloom, Bloom’s Major Dramatists: Christopher Marlowe (Chelsea House, 2002), p.10.  Robert Logan, Shakespeare’s Marlowe: The Influence of Christopher Marlowe on Shakespeare’s Artistry (Ashgate, 2007), p.8.  For a comprehensive list of scholarly quotes about Marlowe’s importance to Shakespeare, go to http://www.marloweshakespeare.org/MarloweScholarship.html
2David Riggs, The Words of Christopher Marlowe (Faber, 2004, 7-9).
3http://www2.prestel.co.uk/rey/baines1.htm

 Click here for the blog's home page and recent content.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Peter Farey Is Co-Winner of Hoffman Prize a Second Time

Last Wednesday's edition of The Times newspaper contained an announcement that our regular contributor Peter Farey had been awarded a half-share in the 2012 Hoffman Prize. Regular readers of the blog will know that this is the second time that he has achieved this, so we asked him the following question:

Q: Peter, congratulations on co-winning the 2012 Calvin and Rose G. Hoffman Prize for a Distinguished Publication on Christopher Marlowe. You had previously won the award in 2007 for your essay "Hoffman and the Authorship." Your entry this year was entitled “Arbella Stuart and Christopher Marlowe.” Can you briefly summarize the essay for us?

PF: Thanks, Carlo.  I am of course delighted to be successful a second time, although my subject is not quite as contentious this year, having a less obvious connection with the dreaded "authorship question."

In Charles Nicholl's mostly excellent book The Reckoning, he added an Appendix of what he called "false trails," one of which concerned a man called "Morley" who had for some three and a half years "read to" – in other words tutored – Arbella Stuart.  A direct descendant of Henry VII, and first cousin to James VI of Scotland, she was born in England, and probably the most likely person to accede to the throne of England if James was barred as a foreigner.  Nicholl considered the question of whether this Morley could have actually been our Christopher, but he reluctantly concluded that "the balance is probably against the tutor being Marlowe," and Sarah Gristwood, author of the most recent biography of Arbella, agreed with him.

The main reason for their conclusion – a view apparently shared by most of Marlowe's other biographers – was that for most of the period in question (1589–1592), Arbella was probably in Derbyshire when we know Marlowe to have been occupied elsewhere. By taking a close look at Arbella's travels away from Derbyshire at other times, however, my essay challenges the assumption that she must have been constantly in Derbyshire during this period, and finds that it is certainly need not be the impediment that the biographers seem to assume.

We also know that the tutor Morley had left university – which, given the role we are talking about, would almost certainly have been either Oxford or Cambridge – a year or two before 1589. I therefore looked at all those coming down from either of them in the preceding twenty years, who had a name which might be morphed into "Morley" and who was not known to be otherwise engaged between 1589 and 1592. Only one person fitted the bill – Christopher Marlowe.

I am not the only Marlovian to have studied this question over the years, of course, and much of what I mentioned had already been noted by others. Ros Barber included (and argued for) the idea in her The Marlowe Papers, for example, and John Baker had a letter about it published in Notes & Queries as well as posting an essay on his website. What I tried to do, therefore, was to put all of the relevant information together  – with a few additional findings of my own – in such a way that it would be hard for anyone not to conclude that Morley the tutor most probably was Christopher Marlowe, placed to spy on Arbella by the Queen's right-hand-man, William Cecil, Lord Burghley.
 
 © The Marlowe-Shakespeare Connection, December 2012

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

The Mysterious Connection Between Thomas Nashe, Thomas Dekker, and T. M.: An English Renaissance Deception?

Christopher Marlowe’s friend, the brilliant humorist Thomas Nashe, often got himself into trouble with authorities. His problems worsened in the summer of 1597, when he was banished from London for co-authoring a “seditious” play. Two years later, he was banned from publishing altogether. Donna Murphy’s The Mysterious Connection Between Thomas Nashe, Thomas Dekker, and T. M.: An English Renaissance Deception? presents substantial linguistic evidence that Nashe reentered London under the name “Thomas Dekker,” that he permanently assumed the identity after he could no longer publish under his own name, and then “killed” himself off. We recently caught up with Donna Murphy to discuss her latest book.

Q: What methodology did you use?

DM: I ran word juxtapositions in the works of Nashe and Dekker through the searchable Early English Books Online database. A large pile up of uncommon juxtapositions between works by “both” authors, plus style similarities, provide reasonable grounds for suspicion. These similarities occur across such a chronologically diverse range of works as to make the explanations of imitation or parody quite unlikely. I used the same methodology to locate other works by Dekker/Nashe, including pieces attributed to T. M., Adam Evesdropper, Jocundary Merry-brains, and Jack Daw.

Q: That all sounds fascinating, but this is a blog about Christopher Marlowe. Why should Marlovians care about Thomas Nashe?

DM:  One reason is that Marlovians believe Marlowe pretended to die yet continued writing, employing William Shakespeare as his front man. My book claims that his friend Nashe did so too, with a twist. In Nashe’s case, I believe he became “Dekker,” who “came to life” in historical records January, 1598.

Q: Didn’t Marlowe and Nashe write Dido, Queen of Carthage together?

DM: So it says on the play’s title page, but there is no hint of Nashe’s style in Dido, and I concur with many others who don’t think Nashe co-authored it. Extensive research convinces me, however, that they often worked together. Although only Marlowe’s name is on the title page of Doctor Faustus, for example, for numerous reasons I view Nashe to have been responsible for much of its prose humor. With the caveat that neither of the two extant versions of Doctor Faustus contains exactly the original version, and thus could have been revised by others, in the 1604 version (Romany and Lindsey Penguin edition) I would tentatively assign to Nashe Scenes ii, iv, vi, vii.109-62, viii.50-99, ix (except for ix.36-41), and xi.1-28, 35-85, and Marlowe the remainder.

Q: What implications does a Marlowe/Nashe partnership have on the Shakespeare authorship issue?

DM: If you get to know Nashe and his writing style by reading my book, you will start to wonder whether some of the verbage in Shakespeare that doesn’t “sound” Marlovian may have been written by Nashe. That’s the topic of my next book, in which I present linguistic evidence that certain anonymous and Shakespeare works were a collaboration between Marlowe and Nashe (I’ll also discuss works I view as by Marlowe without Nashe).

Q: Thanks, Donna.  By the way, blog readers can read a PDF with the table of contents and first twenty pages of the book, as well as order it, by visiting Cambridge Scholars Publishing and entering The Mysterious Connection under “Title.”

© The Marlowe-Shakespeare Connection, November 2012

Donna N. Murphy specializes in researching the authorship of works written during the English Renaissance, and her most recent article is “‘The Life and Death of Jack Straw’ and George Peele” in the December 2012 issue of Notes and Queries. She is a co-winner of the 2010 Calvin and Rose G. Hoffman Prize.